Couple fighting

What is Discernment Counseling?

Many popular theories or frameworks for couples counseling fail to acknowledge that often times one person wants to be in the relationship, and another person is hanging on by a thread or at least not sure that they want to continue. The Gottman Method has a lot of great tools but is often criticized for being too simplistic and making the possibility of divorce or separation a virtual footnote in their several hundred-page manual. Emotionally Focused Therapy (EFT) also has been criticized for assuming that both members are there to make things work. In fact, it wasn’t until 2008 that the notion of specific approaches to working with mixed-agenda couples came about as an evidence-based practice. Many schools do not teach anything about discernment counseling.

Discernment counseling is a brief form of therapy designed to help the couple, and especially the person who is trying to decide if they want to stay, to come to that decision. Discernment counseling often takes only one to five sessions. Couples generally explore three possible paths. The first is they essentially do nothing and continue with the status quo. The second is that they pursue divorce or separation. The third is that they commit to what can be up to six months of counseling and give their best efforts to make things work. All three approaches acknowledge that the relationship may just not work, but even going through the process can have other benefits.

Discernment counseling explores what happened to the relationship (because presumably it was good at one time or it never would have developed). It asks each partner to consider their role (it usually takes two) and what they can change. It brings up the possibility of the impact on children if there is a role that children could play.

The person who is considering leaving generally needs to be the person who decides they at least want to explore whether they make sense as a couple and want the relationship to continue. The discernment process can help couples who may choose to separate to at least realize what they could do better in future relationships and how to separate more amicably. Often to the disappointment of the person who wants to stay in the relationship, discernment counseling needs to be low pressure, or it tends to not work, is just an extension of what the couple is already in disagreement about at home and wastes the clients time.

If there is a mixed agenda, it is important to have a counselor who is trained in discernment counseling. Traditional couples therapy just does not work in most cases until the couple has decided if they are both wanting to stay in the relationship or at least are at a point where they are ready to try traditional couples therapy.

Next Steps
Wellness counseling exercise and mental healthHave questions, call 614.327.1600 or contact us


Scroll to Top